I really wanted to give Wafa like a 3.75 but rating system only allows whole numbers. Wafa is a good scent. I get the Black phantom/Carlisle vibes which youtuber Aromatix was talking about. I would say it is 65/35 BP/Carlisle. The opening is a little weird to me on skin though. But once it the top notes dissapate, it becomes really nice in mid and full drydown. Warm, chocolatey, sweet, and touch of leather is probably the best way I can describe the scent overall. If this was'nt being compared to those high end frags I would probably give it a 3.9. Nice addition tho.